Children |
| 1. Phebe Bailey ATHERTON, b. 21 Dec 1842, Caneadea, Allegany, New York, USA , d. 22 Nov 1934, Geneseo, Livingston, New York, USA (Age 91 years) |
| 2. Sarah Louise ATHERTON, b. 1845, Allegany, Catteraugus, New York, USA , d. Jun 1882, Oramel, Allegany, New York, USA (Age 37 years) |
| 3. Augusta Julia ATHERTON, b. 30 Oct 1847, Caneadea, Allegany, New York, USA , d. 15 Jan 1919, New York, USA (Age 71 years) |
| 4. Cecil ATHERTON, b. 1849, New York, USA |
| 5. Lydia ATHERTON, b. 1850, Caneadea, Allegany, New York, USA |
| 6. John Spencer ATHERTON, b. 20 Feb 1852, Caneadea, Allegany, New York, USA , d. 30 Dec 1898, Oramel, Allegany, New York, USA (Age 46 years) |
| 7. Lovina Dayton ATHERTON, b. 24 Sep 1854, Caneadea, Allegany, New York, USA |
|